What sits between the eye and the paint

Every assessment of colour in a Rembrandt painting is, to some degree, a judgement about what is sitting on top of it. Varnish — the resinous coating applied to finished pictures to protect the surface and saturate the colours — yellows as it ages. What reads as a warm amber tone, a muted sky, or a face emerging from shadow may partly be the paint and partly be accumulated decades of darkened resin.

The resins used in the seventeenth-century Netherlands were typically natural materials: mastic and dammar dissolved in turpentine, or harder resins such as amber. Mastic, the most common choice for finishing coats, is a plant exudate from Pistacia lentiscus that dries quickly and polishes well but yellows significantly over time.


Dammar, tapped from Southeast Asian trees, behaves slightly better in the long term, though it too discolours and becomes brittle. Whether Rembrandt or his workshop applied a final varnish routinely, and what they used, is not always recoverable from the works themselves — later applications have often obscured or replaced whatever was there originally.

A polished sample block under a microscope showing distinct stacked coloured bands
Paint cross-sections. A sample the size of a pinhead, mounted and polished, shows every layer in order. Read the entry

Yellowing, darkening, and the problem it creates

A thick, aged varnish layer does more than shift the overall tone. It can fill the microscopic texture of an impasto passage, reducing the play of light across ridges that were put there precisely to work in raking light.

It can pool in the hollows of the paint surface, creating uneven optical density. It absorbs atmospheric grime, which bonds into the varnish matrix and is then difficult to remove selectively. The result is a picture seen through a filter that is rarely uniform across the surface.

For pictures as dependent on tonal relationships as Rembrandt's — where a face is modelled by the lightest lights and the darkest shadows held in careful balance — this matters considerably. Paint cross-sections occasionally reveal multiple varnish layers of different ages, showing that pictures have been revarnished several times over their history, each application adding to the optical burden.

X-radiography and infrared reflectography work below the varnish layer and are unaffected by it, but any assessment made by eye, including those recorded in connoisseurship literature from Abraham Bredius onward, is based on the varnished surface.


A binocular microscope positioned over a paint surface with an adult conservator looking through it
Under the microscope the question narrows: what is the order of the layers, and what is in each of them.

Cleaning — the careful removal of aged varnish using solvents — is among the most technically demanding and debated procedures in conservation. Solvent action is difficult to control when the varnish and the uppermost paint layer have similar solubility.

Glazes are especially vulnerable: thin transparent layers over opaque paint, already fugitive in some cases, can be partially removed along with the varnish if the chemistry is misjudged. The glazes in these pictures that have survived at all are sometimes considered so precarious that full cleaning is deferred indefinitely.


It can pool in the hollows of the paint surface, creating uneven optical density.

What examination has recovered and what it cannot

The Cultural Heritage Agency of the Netherlands and the conservators at institutions such as the Rijksmuseum and the Mauritshuis have developed protocols for cleaning that proceed in small test areas and document every step, using optical microscopy and cross-section analysis to monitor what is being removed.

The results, when published, routinely reveal that colours were lighter, cooler, and more differentiated in tone than the pre-cleaning surface suggested. Passages read as near-black are sometimes found to carry blue or green underlayers that the varnish had swamped.


A conservator's swab and small dish beside a picture surface under a lamp, close
Glazes and their fading. Transparent coloured layers over opaque paint are where much of the depth comes from, and some of them are the first thing to go. Read the entry

Yet varnish also conceals damage. A picture that looks stable and coherent under an old coating may, once that layer is removed, show extensive retouching from previous restoration campaigns — fills, overpaints and toned-down areas that were put there before an earlier revarnishing.

Cleaning trades one form of visual distortion for a more accurate view of the paint, but also for a more accurate view of everything that has been done to it since it left the workshop.

Solvent action is difficult to control when the varnish and the uppermost paint layer have similar solubility.

The varnish layer is not an obstacle to understanding a painting so much as it is part of the painting's history. It records time.

Extreme close view of a thickly painted cream and ochre highlight on an oil painting surface, the ridges of paint casting small shadows under a side light
Lead white and impasto. The paint is loaded thickly enough to cast its own shadow, so some of the light in the picture is real light falling on real ridges. Read the entry

Passages read as near-black are sometimes found to carry blue or green underlayers that the varnish had swamped.

Small heaps of earth pigment powder in ochre and brown on a stone slab with a muller
Earth pigments. Ochres and umbers are cheap, stable and do most of the work in these paintings. Read the entry